Why Are More People Driving for Uber/Lyft Than Ever?

Over the past decade, the Rideshare industry has transformed urban transportation. Uber, the largest player in the space, has seen its driver base grow year after year (up to 8 million as of the last earnings report). Yet, a strange paradox has emerged: while more people are driving for Uber than ever before, many drivers report that their earnings have declined significantly over the past five years (Gridwise, Len Sherman reports). So why are more people joining a platform that so many say pays less and treats them worse than it used to?

The answer lies in a complex mix of economic pressures, labor market shifts, platform psychology, and gig economy realities.

Let’s explore what’s really happening.

1. Low Barriers to Entry: The Gig Economy’s Open Door

One of the main reasons more people drive for Uber is simple: it’s easy to start. Unlike traditional employment, becoming an Uber driver doesn’t require a degree, years of experience, or a long interview process. If you have a driver’s license, a qualifying vehicle, and can pass a background check, you can be earning money within days if not hours.

This low barrier to entry makes rideshare driving a go-to option for anyone in urgent need of income. It’s the ultimate financial safety net: flexible, fast, and always hiring. In an economy where job security is elusive and benefits are shrinking, Uber offers a lifeline.

2. Economic Pressure: Inflation, Layoffs, and Income Gaps

Between 2020 and 2025, economic uncertainty has plagued many American households. Inflation has driven up the cost of food, housing, gas, and everyday expenses. Meanwhile, wages in traditional jobs have not kept pace with the cost of living.

The pandemic triggered waves of layoffs, especially in the service and tech industries. Even as the economy rebounded, many workers found themselves underemployed or struggling to make ends meet. Uber, despite its declining pay, became a financial bridge for many.

Rather than rely solely on low-paying full-time jobs, people increasingly cobble together multiple income streams. Uber fits neatly into that patchwork. For some, it’s the second job. For others, it’s a side hustle. For many, it’s a way to pay this month’s bills.

3. The Gross vs. Net Illusion: A Misleading Picture

Uber often promotes high earnings potential ads that suggest drivers can make $30-$40 per Active Hour! (with a passenger in the back seat). And on some days, during peak times or special promotions, that can be true. But what these advertisements fail to mention is that these are gross earnings before expenses.

What’s left after gas, maintenance, insurance, depreciation, and Uber’s cut is often far less. In many cases, net earnings after expenses fall below minimum wage in many cities. But many new drivers don’t realize this until they’ve been driving for weeks or months. By then, they’re already invested and about to burn out! 

This disconnect between gross and net pay contributes to high turnover but also continual onboarding. Uber never runs out of people willing to give it a try, even if many eventually leave disillusioned.

4. Platform Incentives and Short-Term Gains

Another reason more people are driving for Uber, despite declining long-term value, is the abundance of short-term incentives. Uber routinely offers:

• Sign-up bonuses

• Weekly earnings guarantees

• Quest and streak bonuses

• Surge pricing and promotions

These can make driving appear lucrative—especially to new drivers. For someone looking to earn quick cash, the idea of making $500 over a weekend is appealing. But once those bonuses dry up, earnings often plummet.

Uber understands this churn-burn-replace cycle and has built its driver acquisition strategy around it. Drivers may not stick around forever, but as long as new ones keep signing up, the supply remains steady. However, over the past few years, there has been a major decline in driver and vehicle quality!

5. The Flexibility Factor: Autonomy Still Matters

Many drivers stay with Uber not because they earn a lot, but because they value freedom. Unlike traditional jobs, rideshare driving allows people to set their own hours. That flexibility is a powerful motivator, especially for:

• Parents who need to work around childcare

• Students balancing classes

• Retirees supplementing income

• Full-time workers seeking side gigs

Even if pay isn’t great, the autonomy to work when and where you want still carries significant value. For some, that freedom offsets lower earnings and safety issues!

6. Uber Needs More Drivers to Maintain Service Levels

Uber’s business model relies on fast response times and driver availability (supply). In order to keep wait times low and maximize ride volume, Uber must have a deep bench of available drivers in every city.

To maintain that availability, Uber casts a wide net, constantly recruiting new drivers through digital ads, referral programs, and app notifications. This has resulted in a steadily growing driver pool, even as per-driver earnings decline due to oversaturation.

Moreover, Uber counts anyone who logs into the app as a "driver," even if they only drive a few hours a week. So the growing number of drivers may not reflect a healthy ecosystem—it may reflect desperation or part-time dabbling.

7. Part-Time and Casual Drivers: The New Normal

The profile of the average Uber driver has shifted. Whereas many early adopters in the 2010s were full-time drivers chasing high payouts, today’s drivers are more likely to work part-time or seasonally.

This shift means:

• People aren’t relying on Uber as a career.

• They’re using it to fill temporary financial gaps.

• They often drive during holidays, major events, or just weekends.

This casual relationship to the platform keeps driver numbers high, but it also means fewer people are depending on Uber for their entire livelihood (about 25% are full time drivers). That makes the drop in earnings more tolerable, for now.

8. Financial Desperation and the Erosion of Alternatives

In many parts of the U.S., especially in smaller cities and rural areas, economic opportunities are limited. Uber and other gig apps have filled that vacuum.

As traditional middle-class jobs have eroded in manufacturing, retail, even customer service, many people have turned to gig work as a last resort. For immigrants, workers without degrees, or older adults pushed out of the workforce, Uber may be the only job available that pays something.

Desperation drives labor supply, even when the compensation is inadequate.

9. Psychological Traps: Sunk Costs and the Hope of a Better Day

Driving for Uber can be psychologically addicting. When a driver has a bad day, they often tell themselves, "Tomorrow will be better." That hope, combined with Uber’s carefully tuned gamification system (surge, quests, ratings, rewards), keeps people on the road longer than they might otherwise stay.

Add to that the sunk-cost fallacy "I already put 1,000 miles on my car; I need to make it worth it" or “I need to reach my daily goal” and many drivers feel compelled to keep going, even when their profit margins vanish.

10. Uber’s Strategy: Churn Is Built Into the Business Model

Uber doesn’t need every driver to stick around long-term. In fact, its model thrives on constant churn. New drivers are cheaper to acquire, more motivated by bonuses, and less aware of the platform's downsides.

By the time drivers burn out, Uber has already replaced them with newer recruits. This model works for Uber at least for now but it keeps earnings low and creates a revolving door of frustrated workers.

My Take: The Gig Economy Paradox

The reason more people are driving for Uber than ever isn’t because it pays well! . It’s because the economy increasingly leaves people with few other choices. Uber offers a quick, flexible way to earn some cash but not necessarily to build a sustainable income. Drivers need a reality check! They should always ask themselves, am I profitable? Uber driving is not public transportation or service, we are in it for ourselves!

It’s the gig economy paradox: even when it pays less, more people need it.

Until systemic changes are made to improve worker protections, increase wage transparency, and provide meaningful alternatives, Uber will continue to attract drivers. But the frustration, burnout, and financial struggles will likely remain just as widespread.

Did someone forward you this newsletter? Subscribe now for free so you never miss an update…

Never miss a Rideshare Guy update…

Twitter/X │ YouTube │ Instagram │Facebook │ LinkedIn │ TikTo