The 5 Rides I Always Decline: Develop Your Selection Strategy

— By Jay Cradeur —

Most drivers think success in rideshare is about taking more rides. It isn’t. It’s about knowing which rides to refuse. 

That may sound counterintuitive, especially if you’re newer or feeling financial pressure. Still, after years behind the wheel, I’ve learned that saying “yes” too often is the fastest way to destroy your hourly rate, your energy, and eventually your motivation.

This article breaks down the five types of trips I consistently decline and explains why saying “no” is often the most profitable move a driver can make. These decisions aren’t emotional or personal. They’re based on math, experience, and understanding how small losses compound over a shift, a week, and a year.

The 5 Rides I Always Decline as a Rideshare Driver

After 10 years and more than 32,000 rides, I stopped thinking like a driver and started thinking like a business owner. That shift changed everything. Acceptance rate stopped mattering. “Being busy” stopped feeling productive. What mattered instead was profit per hour, energy management, and long-term sustainability.

Once you see rideshare as a business, declining bad rides stops feeling risky and starts feeling responsible. Below are the five rides I almost always pass on, and why doing so has kept me profitable long after many drivers burned out.

1. The Under $30 Ride

(If it won’t net at least $30 per hour, it’s a hard pass.)

The math never lies. A six-dollar ride that takes 10 minutes looks harmless on the surface, but it’s anything but. When you factor in a five-minute pickup time, traffic, repositioning afterward, and fuel, that ride almost always produces sub-minimum-wage earnings. It’s not “easy money.” It’s negative leverage against your time.

One of the biggest mistakes drivers make is looking at rides in isolation instead of as part of a flowing system. That $6 trip doesn’t just pay poorly on its own. It blocks you from accepting a better request that could have come in during those same 15 minutes. Declining low-return rides immediately raises your average hourly income, even if you complete fewer trips overall.

Protecting your hourly floor is the fastest way to stabilize income. During busy hours, one bad ride can crowd out two or three profitable ones. When I decline an under-$30-per-hour ride, I’m not rejecting work. I’m protecting my business model.

2. The Short Ride with a Long Wait

(When a 2–5 minute trip quietly wrecks your hourly rate.)

Short rides aren’t inherently bad. In fact, on paper, they can look great. A ride that takes five minutes to reach the passenger and another five minutes to complete, for five dollars, appears to be a solid $30-per-hour proposition. Ten minutes of work for five dollars feels efficient, especially during busy periods when requests are stacking.

The problem begins when the passenger isn’t ready. If that same rider uses the full five minutes of wait time before getting into your car, the math changes completely. What was once a ten-minute transaction is now a fifteen-minute transaction. You’ve gone from earning at a $30-per-hour pace to barely $20 an hour, and that’s before factoring in fuel, car wear, or the opportunity cost of missing another request.  

This is where short rides become dangerous. Because the base trip is so brief, any delay is magnified. Waiting five minutes on a long airport run barely registers. Waiting five minutes on a five-minute ride destroys the economics. The shorter the trip, the less margin you have for inefficiency.

That’s why I pay close attention to behavior at pickup on these rides. When a passenger on a short trip isn’t curb-ready, the profitability collapses almost instantly. You don’t get paid more for waiting, but you absolutely pay for it in lost time. 

Over a full shift, a few of these skewed rides can quietly drag down your average hourly earnings without you realizing why.  It’s not the short ride that’s the problem. It’s the potential wait that comes with it. When time is the product you’re selling, protecting it is everything.

3. The Long Haul to Nowhere

(A long ride that dumps you in a dead zone.)

Not all long rides are bad, but many are deceptive. A 45-minute trip looks attractive until you realize where it ends. Suburbs, industrial parks, rural edges of metro areas. Places where no return fares are waiting. 

When that happens, you’re paid for the trip there, but not for the 45 to 60 minutes it often takes to drive back.  Every experienced driver eventually maps their “no-return zones.” These are areas where demand drops to near zero once you arrive. Getting stranded there during a high-demand window is costly. You don’t just lose time. You miss airport runs, surges, events, and stacked requests happening elsewhere.

Opportunity cost is brutal on these rides. A single poorly timed long haul can erase the gains of an entire peak hour. Long rides are only good when they end where money is circulating. Otherwise, they quietly hollow out your day.

4. The 4.7 Deadbeat Passenger

(Low ratings always have a story.)

Passenger ratings exist for a reason. Drivers rarely down-rate riders unless something genuinely problematic happened: rudeness, arguments, messes, entitlement, or constant complaints. A 4.7 rating doesn’t come from one bad ride. It comes from a pattern.

When I see a low passenger rating, I see data. Multiple drivers had negative experiences and took the time to reflect on that. Ignoring those signals almost always leads to stress. Low-rated passengers are statistically more likely to argue, slam doors, spill drinks, demand exceptions, or claim the destination is wrong mid-trip.

These rides are high-risk and low-reward. They drain mental energy and often pay the same as low-stress alternatives. Even when nothing goes wrong, you spend the entire ride tense, waiting for something to happen. That vigilance costs you more than you realize over a shift.

5. The Multi-Stop Trap

(“Can we just stop real quick?”)

Multi-stop rides sound reasonable in theory. In practice, they rarely are. If I catch the multi-stop designation at the ping, I always decline.  

Sometimes I miss it, and get surprised when I start the ride and see multiple stops.  A three-minute stop becomes ten. Ten becomes fifteen. And suddenly your “short” ride has turned into a drawn-out waiting game with no compensation.  Now, I tell the passengers they have five minutes.  If they take five minutes and one second, I end the ride and move on.  

Then there are the passengers who ask for a stop during the ride. Specific stops are repeat offenders: cigarettes, alcohol runs, and fast food. These stops introduce lines, delays, indecision, and awkward waiting. Worse, once you agree to the first stop, you lose control of the ride. The passenger’s schedule becomes your schedule.

The final insult is the tip. Multi-stop riders rarely tip in proportion to the inconvenience. In fact, many tip less, not more. The extra effort is seldom acknowledged. That mismatch between effort and reward is why I skip these rides whenever possible.

Key Takeaways

Declining rides isn’t being picky. It’s being professional. Profit in rideshare comes from protecting time, energy, and focus. The most important decision you make during a shift isn’t which ride you accept. It’s which ones you refuse.

Saying no requires confidence, especially early on, but guilt has no place in a business. You are not obligated to subsidize inefficiency or poor behavior. Say no. Don’t apologize for it. And don’t feel guilty. 

The drivers who last are the ones who learn that discipline beats hustle every time. 

Be safe out there.

Did someone forward you this newsletter? Subscribe now for free so you never miss an update…

Never miss a Rideshare Guy update…

Twitter/X │ YouTube │ Instagram │Facebook │ LinkedIn │ TikTok